✅ You Have the Right to Choose Your Body Shop
It’s a fairly common scenario: an insurance company suggests (or strongly recommends) a specific body shop after your car accident. But the big question is: do you have to use that body shop?
Short answer: No, you can choose where your vehicle is repaired. It’s important to know your rights so you can make the best decision. You do not have to use the insurance company’s body shop. It’s in the insurance companies’ best interest if you use “there” body shop.
🔍 Why Insurance Companies Recommend Their Own Body Shops
Insurance companies typically have preferred partnerships with certain body repair shops, sometimes called “direct repair programs” (DRPs). These arrangements benefit the insurer, because they streamline claims, reduce costs, and make the process smoother for them.
- They may offer a “lifetime guarantee” on repairs, at least on paper.
- They make it easier for you to get a rental car, drop off the vehicle, and get back on the road.
- They simplify the claims process, which saves the insurer time and money.
🏢 The Benefits of Using the Insurance Company’s Body Shop
When you file a claim after a car accident, your insurance company may recommend one of their preferred repair shops. These shops often belong to what’s called a Direct Repair Program (DRP), a network of body shops that work closely with insurers. While you’re never required to use them, there are a few benefits worth understanding.
🛡️ Lifetime Guarantee on Repairs
Most insurance companies promote a lifetime guarantee on repairs done through their preferred shops. In most cases, this means your repairs are covered for as long as you own the vehicle.
However, here’s the catch — 👇
It’s the body shop, not the insurance company, that provides and upholds this warranty. So, while it’s still a valuable benefit, it’s important to know who is actually backing it. And the truth is, most body shops offer this warranty regardless is they are a DRP.
⚙️ It’s Like Hitting the “Easy” Button
Using the insurance company’s shop can feel effortless.
🚗 You drop your vehicle off.
🚙 They help arrange a rental car.
📄 The adjuster handles everything directly with the shop.
Sounds convenient, right? It is, but there’s a trade-off.
Some insurance companies will disassemble your car at their facility to write a more accurate repair estimate. If you later decide to take your vehicle somewhere else, you could end up getting it back partially taken apart, which can delay the process and add frustration.
⏱️ Faster Handling of Supplements
When additional damage (called a supplement) is discovered during the repair, the insurance company’s body shop can usually handle it right away.
💬 Since the adjuster and shop are already working together, they can approve and complete extra repairs more quickly, no long waits for authorization.
However, this isn’t always guaranteed. While the process can be faster, it also depends on how responsive your insurer is and how busy the repair center may be.
🤝 Why Insurance Companies Prefer It
Insurance companies love efficiency. By encouraging you to use their preferred shops, they can:
- Streamline the claims process 🧾
- Cut down on paperwork and delays 📉
- Help adjusters handle more cases in less time ⏳
The result? A smoother, faster process for them, and often for you too.
⚠️ What the Fine Print Often Leaves Out
While using the insurer’s preferred shop can feel easy, there are potential downsides to be aware of:
- Labor rates may be lower due to the insurance company’s contract with the body shop, which means the shop may be working under tighter margins.
- Aftermarket or used parts may be used instead of brand-new OEM (original equipment manufacturer) parts, especially if the insurer claims your vehicle is “not new” anymore.
- Supplements (hidden or additional damage found during repairs) might be handled differently, possibly with more delays if you use a shop outside the insurer’s network.
- Even though a lifetime warranty is promised, it’s actually the body shop, not the insurance company, that must uphold that guarantee.
🧭 When the Insurance Companies Body Shop Might Make Sense
While you’re never required to use the body shop recommended by your insurance company, there are situations where choosing one of their preferred repair facilities can be a practical and stress-free option.
Here are a few times when it might make sense 👇
😌 You Want a Hassle-Free Experience
If convenience is your top priority, using a preferred shop can feel like pressing the “easy button.”
- The insurer and shop already have a working relationship, which means less back-and-forth for you.
- Paperwork, estimates, and approvals are often handled automatically between them.
- You can typically drop your car off, pick up a rental, and get back on the road the same day.
💡 Perfect for: Drivers who don’t want to deal with logistics or multiple phone calls.
🧾 The Shop Has a Strong Reputation
Not all preferred shops are the same. Some have excellent reputations for quality workmanship, use of OEM parts, and responsive customer service.
- Look for shops with consistent ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ reviews and manufacturer certifications (like I-CAR Gold Class).
- Confirm that they use genuine parts and provide written warranties for all work performed.
🔍 Tip: You can research the shop independently before agreeing to repairs, even if it’s on the insurer’s list.
⏱️ You Need Repairs Done Quickly
When time is critical, for example, if your vehicle is your primary means of transportation, preferred shops often have the advantage of speed.
- Because they’re already in the insurer’s network, repairs can begin almost immediately after the estimate is approved.
- Supplement approvals (for hidden damage) are often processed faster.
🚗 Good to know: This efficiency can help you get your car back on the road days sooner than an independent shop waiting for adjuster approval.
💬 Communication Is Streamlined
One major benefit of using the insurance company’s partner shop is simplified communication.
- The adjuster and the shop coordinate directly, keeping your repair moving forward without delay.
- You’ll often get text or email updates automatically as your vehicle moves through each repair stage.
📱 This can provide peace of mind, especially if you prefer frequent updates without having to chase them.
⚖️ The Bottom Line
Using a preferred shop can offer speed, simplicity, and convenience, particularly when you trust the repair process and the shop’s reputation.
However, always remember:
- You’re never obligated to use the insurer’s chosen shop.
- You can compare multiple estimates before deciding.
- The best choice is the one that gives you confidence in both the workmanship and the integrity of the repairs.
🛠️ What You Should Ask When Choosing Your Body Shop
Selecting the right body shop after a car accident is just as important as choosing the right doctor for an injury. The quality of the repair affects your vehicle’s safety, performance, and resale value, so it’s worth asking the right questions before handing over your keys.
Here are some key questions (and why they matter):
🧩 Will You Use OEM Parts If Requested?
Always ask if the shop will use OEM (Original Equipment Manufacturer) parts, those made by your vehicle’s manufacturer, instead of aftermarket or used parts.
- OEM parts typically fit better, last longer, and maintain your car’s resale value.
- Aftermarket or recycled parts may not perform as well or align perfectly with your vehicle’s design.
🔍 Tip: Ask to see the parts list or estimate so you know exactly what’s being used before repairs begin.
🔎 How Will Hidden Damage or Supplements Be Handled?
During repairs, shops often discover hidden damage that wasn’t visible during the initial inspection. These are called supplements, and how they’re managed can make or break your experience.
- A reputable shop will immediately contact you and the insurance adjuster to get approval before doing extra work.
- Some insurance-recommended shops can handle this on the spot, but independent shops may need more time for re-approval.
💡 Ask: “Will you contact me before making any additional repairs, and how long do supplements usually take to process?”
🧾 What Warranty Do You Back Your Work With?
A trustworthy shop stands behind its work with a written warranty. This shows they’re confident in their craftsmanship and materials.
- Many DRP (Direct Repair Program) shops offer a lifetime warranty. But remember, that promise comes from the shop, not the insurer.
- Independent shops often provide their own warranties, which can be just as strong or even better.
📜 Ask for documentation that outlines how long the warranty lasts and what it covers (parts, labor, paint, etc.).
🚗 Do You Handle Rental Cars and Insurance Communication?
Dealing with transportation and insurance adjusters after a crash can be stressful. A quality shop will help ease that burden.
- Some shops will arrange your rental car directly and bill the insurer on your behalf.
- Others can communicate directly with the insurance company, ensuring paperwork and approvals are handled smoothly.
📞 Ask: “Will you coordinate with my insurance and rental car company, or do I need to handle that myself?”
⚖️ Bonus Question: Are You Certified or Manufacturer-Approved?
This is often overlooked but very important.
- Certifications like I-CAR Gold Class or ASE indicate that technicians are properly trained.
- Some shops are manufacturer-approved (e.g., Honda ProFirst, Ford Certified), meaning they meet specific standards for repair quality.
🏅 Shops with certifications are more likely to perform accurate, safe repairs that protect your vehicle’s warranty and value. By asking these questions upfront, you’ll gain confidence that your car is in skilled hands and that every repair, from paint to parts, meets your expectations for safety and quality.
🔐 You Are Free to Pick Your Own Shop
- You have the right to choose a repair facility the decision belongs to you, as the vehicle owner.
- The insurance company may subtly discourage you (e.g., slower inspections, harder rental arrangements), but that doesn’t change your right.
- If you prefer a body shop you trust, for example, one you’ve used in the past or one that has top reviews, you can absolutely use it.
- If you have full-coverage insurance and the accident wasn’t your fault, you may even have options to file through your own insurer so you get to pick the shop and still recover costs.
📌 Key Takeaways
- You do not have to use the body shop the insurance company recommends.
- Choose a repair facility you trust, one that stands behind its work, uses quality parts, and clearly communicates how supplements and hidden damage will be handled.
- Be aware of the trade-offs with recommended shops (speed and convenience vs. autonomy and quality).
- Ask important questions and don’t feel pressured, your priority should be getting your vehicle safely and correctly repaired.
Connecting Accident Victims with Trusted Injury Doctors Since 2012
