Hiring a personal injury attorney is a big decision, but what happens when you start to feel like your lawyer isn’t meeting your expectations? Whether it’s a lack of communication, delays in your case, or a loss of trust, you might be wondering if it’s time to part ways with your attorney.
Before making a final decision, it’s important to understand the legal process, assess your concerns, and consider the potential consequences of firing your attorney. Let’s find out when it might be appropriate to fire your personal injury lawyer, how to do it properly, and what to consider before making a change.
When Should You Fire Your Personal Injury Attorney?
1. Poor Communication & Unreturned Calls
The most common complaint clients have about their personal injury attorneys is a lack of communication. You may feel left in the dark about the progress of your case, and phone calls or emails might go unanswered.
However, before assuming your lawyer is ignoring you, consider the nature of personal injury cases:
- In the early stages, there may be little activity beyond filing paperwork and notifying the insurance company.
- Much of the real work begins after you complete medical treatment, as your lawyer will then gather records, bills, and lost wage documentation.
- Obtaining medical records can take time, sometimes requiring multiple requests or in-person visits to doctors’ offices.
If your lawyer is not responding to urgent inquiries or consistently ignores your attempts to reach them, that’s a red flag. In such cases, sending an email can sometimes be more effective than calling, as attorneys spend a lot of time on the phone.
If communication remains a problem despite multiple attempts to resolve it, this may be a valid reason to fire your attorney.
2. Your Case Is Taking Too Long
Personal injury cases can take anywhere from a few months to several years to settle. The timeline depends on factors such as:
- The severity of your injuries
- The length of your medical treatment
- Negotiations with the insurance company
- Whether the case goes to trial
If your case is dragging on longer than expected, ask your attorney for a clear explanation of the delays. If they cannot provide one or seem uninterested in expediting the process, it may be time to consider a new lawyer.
3. Frustration with the Legal Process
Many clients get frustrated because they don’t fully understand the personal injury process. Some attorneys fail to explain it thoroughly, leaving clients confused and anxious.
Here’s a general timeline of a personal injury case:
- Attorney sends a letter of representation to the insurance company (can take up to 30 days).
- You complete medical treatment before negotiations can begin.
- Attorney gathers medical records, bills, and wage loss documentation (can take weeks to months).
- Settlement negotiations begin (this process can take several months).
- If a settlement isn’t reached, a lawsuit may be filed, leading to trial (this can take over a year).
Understanding these steps can help set realistic expectations and reduce frustration.
4. Your Attorney Lacks Expertise in Personal Injury Law
Not all attorneys specialize in personal injury cases. Some lawyers take on any case they can get, even if they lack experience in the field. A lawyer who primarily practices bankruptcy or family law may not have the knowledge needed to maximize your injury claim.
If your lawyer seems unfamiliar with personal injury laws, struggles to answer your questions, or lacks trial experience, it may be best to consult a more experienced attorney.
Need a Second opinion on your personal injury case?
5. Unprofessional Behavior
Your attorney should act professionally, ethically, and with integrity. Warning signs of an unprofessional lawyer include:
- Failing to return calls or meet deadlines
- Making inappropriate comments about other attorneys
- Dressing unprofessionally or conducting business in an unorganized manner
- Acting unethically or engaging in dishonest practices
Most attorneys take their job seriously and maintain a high level of professionalism, but if your lawyer exhibits unprofessional behavior, it may be time to find someone who takes your case seriously.
6. You No Longer Trust Your Attorney
Trust is essential in any attorney-client relationship. If your lawyer has made promises they haven’t kept, provided misleading information, or simply lost your confidence, continuing to work with them may not be in your best interest.
Before making any decisions, it’s a good idea to consult another law firm for a second opinion. Be prepared to explain why you are considering switching lawyers—some firms may be hesitant to take a case that has already changed hands multiple times.
How to Fire Your Personal Injury Attorney
If you’ve decided to fire your attorney, here’s how to do it properly:
1. Review Your Contract
Check the agreement you signed when you hired your attorney. Some contracts include clauses about attorney fees if you switch lawyers.
2. Find a New Attorney First
It’s best to have another attorney lined up before firing your current one. Many personal injury attorneys will take care of the transition by requesting your case file from your former lawyer.
3. Notify Your Attorney in Writing
You need to send a written notice stating that you are terminating their services. A simple letter should include:
- Your name and case details
- A clear statement that you are ending representation
- A request for your case file to be transferred to your new attorney (if applicable)
Example:
“I, [Your Name], no longer require the services of [Law Firm Name] effective immediately. Please transfer my case file to [New Attorney’s Name & Contact Information].”
4. Send the Letter via Fax or Certified Mail
To ensure your attorney receives the notice, fax it or send it via certified mail. Keep a copy of the letter and confirmation of receipt.
5. Communicate with Your New Attorney
Provide your new lawyer with any documents related to your case. They will handle the transition and notify the insurance company that they are now representing you.
Can Your Attorney Fire You as a Client?
Yes, attorneys can fire clients as well. Common reasons include:
- Unreasonable demands or attempting to control legal strategy
- Lack of cooperation (e.g., not returning calls or providing necessary documents)
- Requesting money advances on your settlement
- Rude or abusive behavior toward legal staff
If your attorney fires you, you may have difficulty finding another lawyer willing to take your case, especially if it’s near trial.
Final Thoughts: Should You Fire Your Accident Attorney?
Before firing your personal injury attorney, ask yourself:
✔ Have I clearly communicated my concerns?
✔ Have I given my lawyer enough time to work on my case?
✔ Have I reviewed my contract and potential fees?
✔ Do I have another attorney ready to take over?
If you have genuinely tried to resolve your concerns and still feel unsatisfied, firing your attorney may be the best decision. However, be mindful of how it may affect your case, and ensure you follow the proper steps to avoid unnecessary delays or complications.
Considering switching attorneys? Contact us, we can help.